online-learning-challenges

Students: Online courses require more discipline


Online college courses, while extolled for their convenience, accessibility, and low cost, demand more of students who go the nontraditional route, according to findings in a recently released study.

online-education-students
Three in four students say they’re satisfied with online education.

Six in 10 community college students who responded to a survey conducted by the nonprofit Public Agenda said web-based classes require more discipline than simply attending an in-person class. One in 10 said web-based classes require less discipline than in-person classes.

That’s reflected in the 38 percent of student respondents who said online classes are harder to pass than their traditional counterparts. Eighteen percent said online courses are easier.

Perhaps most disturbing for online education advocates: Four in 10 college students said they learned less online than they did in classrooms and lecture halls.

The results from the study, called “Not Yet Sold,” fly directly in the face of previous findings that showed 75 percent of online college students said they were satisfied with their educational experience, compared to 55 percent of traditional college students.

“Just as online education itself is rapidly changing, we expect student and employer attitudes to shift as well,” the report’s authors wrote. “Still, we need to consider the skepticism of those on the ground, especially if we hope to avoid any unintended consequences.”

Employers surveyed by Public Agenda were largely in agreement with students who said online classes demanded a more disciplined approach.

See Page 2 for more web-based class concerns…

Three-quarters of employers said online courses require the same or more discipline as traditional classes.

Measuring students’ perception of the challenges inherent in online education would be a critical step in improving nontraditional education, the report’s authors said.

“As key decision makers face this changing landscape, this research provides important insights from some of those on the ground, in order to ensure that online education can better meet the needs of students and society,” they wrote.

The four in 10 students who said they didn’t learn as much in an online setting isn’t the first piece of recent bad news for campus technologists.

A Noel-Levitz survey released in September charged that “instructional quality” remains the foremost concern among those enrolled in web-based classes.

“Creating connections with students is the great challenge of online education,” said Julie Bryant, associate vice president at Noel-Levitz and author of the report. “How do you keep student interest and involvement when their ‘classroom’ is a computer screen? That’s precisely why so many online programs survey their students about their satisfaction levels.”

Sign up for our newsletter

Newsletter: Innovations in K12 Education
By submitting your information, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Oops! We could not locate your form.

Sign up for our newsletter

Newsletter: Innovations in K12 Education
By submitting your information, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.