2. States that are making the most per-student investments, and spending that money efficiently, are not in the clear. Despite besting the rankings in higher education funding and productivity, Arizona ranks 13th overall, and without significant changes, will struggle to produce enough graduates.

3. While many states in the southeast are the most at risk (Mississippi, Alabama, South Carolina, and Louisiana all rank in the bottom 5), the lower half of the rankings covers the map. This reflects the lack of a national policy for improving access to college.

4. Wealth does not fully mitigate against risk. Connecticut has the second-highest median household income according to the U.S. Census Bureau–but it ranks 44th here.

“The world has changed, but our public policies haven’t,” Finney says. “We’re still touting the successes of a system designed in the wake of World War II to allow 30 to 40 percent of the country, drawn mostly from white, affluent backgrounds, to earn a college degree even though that system now leaves us woefully unprepared for the challenges of the 21st century.”

What should policymakers prioritize to get on track? Finney has these suggestions:

1. Prioritize students who have traditionally been left out of higher education. The nation cannot meet its educational needs by educating more mostly white 18- to 24-year-olds. Low-income, first-generation, minority, and working-adult students need to be supported in ways that have not been seriously attempted on a large scale. Start by focusing support on the institutions that educate most Americans, such as community colleges and regional comprehensive colleges.

2. Rebalance the financial burden. Public colleges have more money flowing through them than ever before, but students are supplying a greater share of that revenue through tuition, while states’ contributions have proportionally fallen. This is a recipe for dropouts and debt, not degrees.

3. Look beyond the education budget. States can’t prioritize higher-ed opportunity based on improved educational performance and equity without stable funding to higher education, the productive use of funds, the development of state reserves for economic downturns, and policies to better manage state debt and public pension liabilities, as well as policies to encourage economic growth and knowledge-based industries.

4. Find partners. Governors, legislators, business leaders, and institutional leaders must collaborate more effectively than in the past few decades in order to put in place a public compact for educational opportunity that will serve states in the decades to come.

About the Author:

Material from a press release was used in this report.


Add your opinion to the discussion.