Survey: College students struggling for loans

The credit crunch has officially arrived on campus: In a new survey, private colleges report their students are finding it significantly harder to secure the private loans they need to pay tuition bills. Furthermore, nearly half of colleges say some students have been forced to take time off or go part-time as a result.

The survey, released Oct. 21 by the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities, confirms anecdotal evidence that the federal financial aid system so far has held up reasonably well during the financial meltdown.

But the survey paints a more troubling picture for students who need private loans to supplement their federal ones.

"We had not expected to find incidences of students already stopping and dropping out," said Sarah Flanagan, vice president for government relations at NAICU. "There are certainly a concerning number of students who have had to change their educational plans because of a lack of credit."

Three-quarters of the 504 schools surveyed reported more requests for institutional aid this year, and despite the largest cohort of 18-year-olds since the Baby Boom, one in five colleges reported a smaller incoming class than expected.

Only about one-quarter of American college students attend private or independent colleges, and they typically have to borrow more than students elsewhere. But they’re also generally considered more attractive lending candidates, Flanagan said, because of factors such as higher graduation rates.

According to last year’s numbers from the College Board, the average list price at public four-year colleges was $6,185, compared to $23,712 at private four-year colleges.

That’s why the findings are troubling: If private college students can’t get loans, students at public, community, and for-profit schools are struggling at least as much.

The survey was conducted in September, before the latest tightening of credit markets.

"There are only so many options. We’ve awarded them the maximum grants and scholarships and loans," said Sue Standley, the financial aid director at Augustana College in Rock Island, Ill., which recently announced next year’s tuition hike of 3.9 percent the lowest in 25 years six months earlier than usual to help students plan ahead. Tuition, fees, room, and board this year run $37,800.

Standley said about 25 students there out of 2,500 total have been unable to secure student loans because they don’t have creditworthy co-signers, and a handful may have to drop out.

Experts agree prompt action last spring by Congress and the Bush administration successfully averted major problems with the federal loan program, chiefly by buying up loans from lenders and providing them capital to make new loans. But student lending through the government is capped, so many still turn to private loans for college costs.

Those loans amounted to at least $18.5 billion in 2006, according to the most recent figures from the College Board. Such loans are the fastest-growing segment of financial aid, surging nearly 900 percent in volume over the last decade.

But as credit markets have tightened, at least 36 lenders have stopped providing private student loans, according to web site, and those remaining have made it harder to borrow. Giant lender Sallie Mae, for instance, recently announced across-the-board credit requirements for private loans, and in the NAICU survey 74 percent of institutions reported students were subjected to tighter credit restrictions.

John E. Dean, special counsel to the Consumer Bankers Association, which represents for-profit student lenders, said the results are "disturbing" but unsurprising, given recent financial turmoil.

He advised students who need private loans for second semester to begin looking early.

"The easiest step … is to bring in a creditworthy co-signer," he said. "That will make a difference on the availability of loans and the price."

Among other NAICU survey findings:

Nearly half of institutions surveyed reported between 11 and 50 students who couldn’t secure a private loan this academic year, and 11 percent had more than 50 such students. Fifty-six percent said the lack of a co-signer was the main reason students were denied.

Asked how students who couldn’t get loans were responding, 46 percent of colleges said at least some were taking time off or going part-time; 38 percent were working; and 34 percent were electing to pay with credit cards.

About one in three institutions reported they were giving more institutional aid to students who were denied private loans. The same proportion also reported seeing more parents apply for federal PLUS loans this year.


National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities

Note to readers:

Don’t forget to visit the Anywhere Anytime Administration resource center. As schools move toward the newest technologies, school administrators need to be reassured that vital information will reach them instantly, whether they are in the office, in a meeting, or traveling across their district or campus. The need for anywhere, anytime access has led many administrators to depend on mobile, handheld devices for eMail and other applications. Go to: Anywhere Anytime Administration